Gary H. and L. Marianne Bell - Page 6

                                        - 5 -                                         
          petitioner transferred $3,500 from his checking account to a                
          separate IRA account in petitioner’s name in America First Credit           
          Union.  Thus the key question we must decide is whether                     
          petitioners received any “compensation” or “earned income” in               
          2002 from which they could deduct the $3,500 contribution made to           
          petitioner’s IRA account.                                                   
               Petitioner’s position is that he is entitled to his IRA                
          deduction in 2002 because the $4,800 he received from his TSP               
          distributions in that year constituted “earned income” he                   
          reported on his tax returns as includable in his gross income.              
          He contends that some of his salary income earned, but not taxed,           
          in prior years, which was deposited in his TSP account, continued           
          to be earned income taxable in years when TSP distributions were            
          made to him.  To the contrary, respondent contends that the                 
          “maximum amount” petitioners may claim for an IRA deduction in              
          2002 is zero because petitioners did not have any “compensation”            
          (which term includes “earned income”) that was includable in                
          their gross income pursuant to the provisions of section                    
          219(b)(1)(B) and (f)(1).  We agree with respondent for the                  
          reasons stated herein.                                                      
               With certain limitations, a taxpayer is entitled to deduct             
          amounts contributed to an IRA.  Sec. 219(a).  The deduction,                
          however, may not exceed the lesser of (1) the deductible amount             
          or (2) an amount equal to the compensation includable in the                






Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011