Raymond T. and Patricia Murphy - Page 9

                                        - 9 -                                         
          during audit.  And the Commissioner invoked his right to exclude            
          the testimony of the accountant who’d prepared Murphy’s tax                 
          returns on the ground that he had not been identified in Murphy’s           
          pretrial memorandum.                                                        
               We are therefore forced to rely mostly on our evaluations of           
          Murphy’s truthfulness and the rather thin paper trail.  And, in             
          the end, we do find that Murphy’s testimony was credible.  Due to           
          the length of his dealings with Hunt, including many successful             
          trades and coownership of some horses, we find that their                   
          relationship was strong enough to explain Hunt’s willingness to             
          extend the payment schedule for Hamseh and Desert Spice.  Apart             
          from unsuccessfully challenging Murphy’s credibility, and despite           
          having the burden of proof on this issue, the IRS provided no               
          direct evidence that Murphy did not owe Hunt money for those two            
          horses when he mailed Hunt the $225,000 check.  We therefore find           
          that Murphy has shown that a valid indebtedness on Hamseh and               
          Desert Spice still existed at the end of 1997.  See First Natl.,            
          289 F.2d at 866 (leniency by lender in not pressing for                     
          collection on debt does not create presumption that debt is                 
          invalid).                                                                   
               The Commissioner next argues that, even if those notes were            
          still outstanding, Murphy must have intended to use the money to            
          repay the principal owed for On the Piste, because $225,000 was             
          the exact amount that Murphy still owed Hunt for that horse.                






Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011