Ana Maria Rodriguez - Page 12

                                       - 11 -                                         
          unusual when compared to the family’s past levels of income,                
          standard of living, and spending patterns, and culpable spouse’s            
          evasiveness and deceit concerning couple’s finances).                       
               Petitioner’s level of education was not made a part of the             
          record; however, given her limited English proficiency, her                 
          understanding of the tax return was likely somewhat limited.                
               Petitioner was responsible for paying the household                    
          expenses, and taking care of her three daughters, while Mr.                 
          Rodriguez was responsible for preparing the couple’s tax returns.           
          We conclude that petitioner was at least somewhat experienced in            
          financial matters and in running a household.  Petitioner also              
          had some control over financial matters because she asked the tax           
          preparer at Lydia’s Tax Service questions regarding certain items           
          relating to Mr. Rodriguez’s income.  Petitioner also testified              
          that she tried to understand the amounts included on the return.            
               The record does not reflect a difference in petitioner’s               
          lifestyle, or the presence of expenditures that appear lavish or            
          unusual in comparison to the family’s past levels of income.                
          Petitioner’s standard of living and spending patterns reflect               
          those of someone attempting to raise three daughters as a single            
          parent on one income.                                                       
               While petitioner testified that she was unaware of the                 
          amount of the IRA distribution, we note that she has previously             
          been granted relief to the extent of the amount not reflected on            






Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011