David E. Benson - Page 13




                                       - 13 -                                         
                        *     *     *     *     *     *     *                         
                    * * * I gave the gifts out on a regular basis, and                
               that was basically it.  They were small gifts, no                      
               receipts needed because they were all under $20.                       
               Petitioner’s testimony fails to establish, inter alia,                 
          (1) the recipient of any claimed gift, (2) the business relation-           
          ship to McKendree or to petitioner of the recipient of any                  
          claimed gift, (3) the amount of any claimed gift, (4) the date of           
          any claimed gift, (5) a description of any claimed gift, or                 
          (6) the business purpose of any claimed gift.  We shall not rely            
          on petitioner’s testimony to establish his position with respect            
          to the claimed gifts.  Except for that testimony, petitioner                
          presented no evidence with respect to the claimed gifts.                    
               The record establishes that McKendree did not require                  
          petitioner to provide gifts to its customers or its potential               
          customers.  The record does not establish that gifts to customers           
          and prospective customers of McKendree were employee business               
          expenses under McKendree’s reimbursement policy.                            
               Assuming arguendo that petitioner had established that he              
          made the claimed gifts to customers and prospective customers of            
          McKendree and that such claimed gifts were employee business                
          expenses under McKendree’s reimbursement policy, petitioner                 
          admitted at trial that he did not submit any reimbursement forms            
          for any such gifts, as required by McKendree’s reimbursement                
          policy.  On the instant record, we find that petitioner has                 







Page:  Previous  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  Next 

Last modified: November 10, 2007