Manuel R. Chavez - Page 7




                                        - 6 -                                         
          Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2000-333.  Thus, a taxpayer who cannot             
          establish the total amount of support costs for the claimed                 
          individual generally may not claim that individual as a                     
          dependent.  Blanco v. Commissioner, 56 T.C. 512, 514-515 (1971);            
          Cotton v. Commissioner, supra.                                              
               Petitioner, petitioner’s sister, and petitioner’s nieces all           
          lived with petitioner’s mother in 2003.  Petitioner testified               
          that he was responsible for paying the rent and all household               
          bills even though the lease and bills were in his mother’s name.            
          Petitioner explained that he gave his mother cash so that she               
          could pay the rent and bills.  However, petitioner did not                  
          present any evidence regarding the dollar amount of money he                
          contributed to the household.                                               
               RJM and CGM received State aid, which included food stamps,            
          during 2003.  With respect to amounts petitioner provided for RJM           
          and CGM’s support, petitioner testified that he gave his sister             
          cash on a regular basis.  Specifically, petitioner testified that           
          he gave his sister at least $100 per month, and that if his                 
          financial situation permitted, he contributed up to $400 or $500            
          a month.  Petitioner did not present any independent evidence to            
          corroborate his testimony.                                                  
               The Court finds petitioner’s testimony to be credible as to            
          the fact that he provided some support for his nieces and                   
          contributed towards household bills.  However, the record is                







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 10, 2007