Ramzy M. and Lena Kopty - Page 7




                                         -7-                                          
         ending August 31, 1998.  That statement records a “stock rollover            
         DS” on August 24, 1998, consisting of 10,323 shares of J.D.                  
         Edwards & Co. stock valued at $40.50 per share in the aggregate              
         amount $418,081.50.  It is not clear from the record why the                 
         rollover was not booked into petitioner’s account as of August 4,            
         1998, the date of the receipt issued by Norwest for petitioner’s             
         J.D. Edwards & Co. stock certificate.                                        
              A letter to petitioner dated August 11, 1998, written by a              
         representative of the ESOP’s trustee, Wells Fargo Bank, states as            
         follows:                                                                     
              You elected to take a distribution from the J.D.                        
              Edwards & Company (the “Company”) Employee Stock                        
              Ownership Plan (the “ESOP”).  In accordance with the                    
              terms of the ESOP and your distribution request form, a                 
              stock certificate in the amount of 10,323 shares. [sic]                 
              You will receive your stock certificate from J.D.                       
              Edwards in the near future.                                             
              You elected not to rollover your ESOP account balance.                  
              As a result, the cash balance, consisting of your cash                  
              account and fractional shares, has been withheld for                    
              tax purposes.  You will receive a 1099R in January 1999                 
              to reflect your distribution.  You may be liable for                    
              additional taxes concerning this distribution.                          
         The above letter is wrong on two important points.  First, as                
         discussed above, by August 11, 1998, the date of the letter,                 
         petitioner had already received the stock certificate for 10,323             
         shares of J.D. Edwards & Co. stock from the transfer agent.                  
         Second, by the date of the letter, petitioner had already hand-              
         delivered the stock certificate to Norwest for deposit into his              
         rollover IRA.                                                                






Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: March 27, 2008