Ramzy M. and Lena Kopty - Page 30




                                        -30-                                          
         petitioners assert that they are not subject to the 10-percent               
         additional tax on early distributions under section 72(t) because            
         all of the distributions are attributable to Mr. Kopty’s being               
         disabled within the meaning of section 72(m)(7).                             
              As to the distributions made during 1999, we do not accept              
         petitioners’ assertion that the distributions are attributable to            
         Mr. Kopty’s being disabled.  According to the medical records                
         submitted by petitioners, Mr. Kopty was briefly treated in the               
         emergency room of the American Hospital in Dubai on November 29,             
         1999, and approximately 1 week later, on December 6, 1999,                   
         returned to engage in a treadmill test.  According to                        
         petitioners’ brief: "petitioner was diagnosed in 1999 with                   
         Pectoris Spasm and Ischemia which limited petitioner’s ability to            
         have gainful activity from 1999 onwards and that the same disease            
         led to an myocardial infarction (MI) in March 2000."  That                   
         diagnosis, however, did not even take place until December 6,                
         1999, at the earliest.  By that time, all of the distributions               
         for 1999 had been made.  In our view, the record of this case                
         fails to show that any of the distributions made during 1999 in              
         the amount of $331,500 were attributable to Mr. Kopty’s being                
         disabled.                                                                    
              As to the distributions made during 2000, Mr. Kopty was                 
         admitted to the American Hospital in Dubai on March 3, 2000, with            
         the symptoms of a heart attack.  Approximately 2 weeks later, he             







Page:  Previous  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  35  36  37  Next 

Last modified: March 27, 2008