Estate of Concetta H. Rector, Deceased, John M. Rector, II, Co-Executor and Co-Trustee - Page 25




                                       - 25 -                                         
          any legitimate concern about the liabilities of decedent, nor did           
          decedent’s transfer of her assets to RLP actually protect the               
          assets from her creditors in that she or her trust was at all               
          times an RLP general partner.  See id.  The estate’s stated claim           
          to a diversification of assets also is not such a purpose in that           
          RLP’s ownership and management of the transferred assets was                
          essentially identical to the 1991 revocable trust’s pretransfer             
          ownership and management of those assets.  We also note that RLP            
          had no investment strategy or business plan of providing added              
          diversification of investments; rather, RLP held the securities             
          transferred by decedent without any substantial change in                   
          investment strategy and did not engage in business transactions             
          with anyone outside of the family.10  See Estate of Thompson v.             
          Commissioner, 382 F.3d at 378 (partnership lacked substantial               
          nontax purpose under similar facts).  Given these findings and              
          conclusions, and our additional findings as to decedent’s age and           
          health at the time of RLP’s formation, as well as the fact that             
          only decedent’s cash and marketable securities were contributed             
          to RLP, we conclude that the formation of RLP was more consistent           



               10 While the estate discerns a business purpose from the               
          banking and securities investments of decedent’s predeceased                
          spouse and his parents, we find that family history to have no              
          bearing on this case.                                                       





Page:  Previous  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  Next 

Last modified: March 27, 2008