Hubert Enterprises, Incorporated, Successor By Merger To Hubert Holding Company - Page 3




                                         -3-                                          
          capital account restoration obligation (DRO) included in the                
          amended and restated operating agreement of Leasing Co., L.L.C.             
          (LCL), a limited liability company, rendered LCL’s members payors           
          of last resort under the law applicable in the Sixth Circuit.               
          Id. at 531.  The relevant years for LCL are its taxable years               
          ended July 31, 2000 and 2001, and LCL’s members added the DRO to            
          LCL’s operating agreement on March 28, 2001, stated as effective            
          January 1, 2000.  LCL’s members are HBW, Inc. (HBW), a wholly               
          owned subsidiary of Hubert Holding Co. (HHC), and Hubert Commerce           
          Center (HCC).  The subject years are HHC’s taxable years ended in           
          July 2000 and 2001.1                                                        
               On remand, we ordered the parties to state the proper course           
          of action to be taken in light of the remand.  Neither party                
          requested any further trial, stating that the mandate of the                
          Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit was best followed through            
          their filing of seriatim briefs.  Accordingly, we decide the                
          relevant issue on the basis of the record underlying Hubert I,              
          with the assistance of additional briefing by the parties.  We              
          incorporate herein our facts as set forth in Hubert I and repeat            
          those facts only as necessary for a comprehensive analysis of the           
          relevant issue.  We hold that the DRO did not render HBW a payor            



               1 For Federal income tax purposes, HHC and HBW reported                
          their operations for those years on the basis of a 52- to 53-week           
          fiscal year ending on the Friday nearest to each July 31.                   





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: March 27, 2008