Hubert Enterprises, Incorporated, Successor By Merger To Hubert Holding Company - Page 18




                                        -18-                                          
          rights or remedies hereunder or by reason hereof.”  We also note            
          the illogic of petitioner’s argument that the DRO in and of                 
          itself makes HBW at risk for the repayment of LCL’s recourse                
          debt.  As we have stated, a DRO is routinely inserted into a                
          partnership agreement to meet the substantial economic effect               
          requirements of section 704(b).  If a member of a limited                   
          liability company is automatically “at risk” for repayment of the           
          company’s recourse debt simply by inserting a DRO in the                    
          operating agreement in order to meet the requirements of section            
          704(b), then the at-risk rules of section 465 have little purpose           
          in that seemingly every member of a limited liability company is            
          at risk for the repayment of the company’s recourse debt.                   
               The limited amount of any capital contribution under the DRO           
          further supports our conclusion that HBW was not a payor of last            
          resort as to LCL’s recourse debt.  Under the DRO, HBW’s                     
          obligation is limited to restoring the amount of any deficit in             
          its capital account.  However, the amount of that deficit, if in            
          fact one occurs, is not necessarily the same amount as HBW’s                
          proportionate share of LCL’s recourse debt.  Moreover, as just              
          noted, the revised operating agreement does not require LCL to              
          pay any or all of the restored deficit to creditors; it allows              
          LCL to distribute any restored funds to members with positive               
          capital account balances.                                                   








Page:  Previous  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  Next 

Last modified: March 27, 2008