Ex parte KEUPER et al. - Page 5




          Appeal No. 96-4122                                                           
          Application 08/077,419                                                       

          inertial reference system.  Claim 1 recites a corresponding                  
          method step.  Claim 11 requires a means for correcting the                   
          first signals, dependent on a correction value that is                       
          dependent on one of several factors.  Claim 1 recites a                      
          corresponding method step.  Claim 11 requires a means for                    
          determining movements of the vehicle relative to a road                      
          surface-fixed reference system dependent on the corrected                    
          first signals.  Claim 1 recites a corresponding method step.                 
          Claim 11 requires a means for controlling the chassis of the                 
          vehicle, dependent on the determined movements.  Claim 1                     
          recites a corresponding step.                                                
               Both independent claims require that vehicle movement be                
          determined relative to a road surface-fixed reference system,                
          that the road surface-fixed reference system is dependent on                 
          corrections made to a set of first signals, and that the first               
          signals represent movements of the vehicle relative to an                    
          inertial reference system.  The examiner’s treatment of these                
          claim limitations is disjointed and missing key relationships.               
               What the examiner has done is (1) find in Majeed a                      
          vehicle chassis control system which uses an inertial                        
          reference system, (2) find in Adachi a vehicle chassis control               

                                          5                                            





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007