Ex parte KEUPER et al. - Page 8




          Appeal No. 96-4122                                                           
          Application 08/077,419                                                       

          independent of any other separate inertial reference system.                 
          According to the claimed invention, the road surface-fixed                   
          reference system must be “dependent” on corrected first                      
          signals which first signals represent movements of the vehicle               
          relative to an inertial reference system.  The examiner cites                
          Chan as teaching the conversion from an inertial vehicle                     
          reference system to a road surface-fixed reference system.                   
          However, the objective of Chan is entirely different.  As is                 
          stated in Chan’s column 17, lines 27-38:                                     
               Sensor data therefore includes the effects of any                       
               aircraft motion.  To reduce the system false alarm                      
               rate to an acceptable level, potential threats must                     
               be tracked in an inertial coordinate system.                            
               Effects of aircraft motion must therefore be                            
               eliminated from the raw sensor data before tracking                     
               can be done.  Three rate-integrating gyros located                      
               at the sensor and strapped down to the aircraft hull                    
               will be able to measure motion caused by aircraft                       
               maneuvers as well as motion caused by aircraft                          
               vibrations, flexure and turbulence.                                     
               Chan’s teaching concerns aircrafts in flight, not wheeled               
          vehicles which travel by frictional contact between wheels and               
          the road surface.  Road surface-fixed reference, in the                      
          context of the appellants’ specification, has no meaningful                  
          significance in Chan.  Chan also seeks to eliminate all                      
          effects of vehicle motion, not just those caused by changes in               

                                          8                                            





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007