Ex Parte PARE - Page 8




                                   analysis evidenced the presence of volatile terpenoids as well as less volatile                                                     
                                   ones.                                                                                                                               
                                   It will be evident to those skilled in the art that the choice of sorbent is                                                        
                                   dependent upon the nature of the volatiles of interest (in the present example,                                                     
                                   a silica sorbent was appropriate). Direct injection of the volatiles without the                                                    
                                   use of any trap of any kind (cold or sorbent) is possible by the use of this                                                        
                                   invention because ofthe short sampling duration and because of the relatively                                                       
                                   small volume of sampling necessary. Purge and trap would not allow such a                                                           
                                   direct injection without a cold trap of kind, or of a sorbent. The use of this                                                      
                                   invention, in this particular example, showed that a purge and trap analysis                                                        
                                   can be performed more rapidly, with less operations (hence reduced risks of                                                         
                                   sample loss or sample degradation), at a much reduced cost and with less                                                            
                                   energy than conventional technology. Again, the use of this invention                                                               
                                   requires less intricate equipment occupying a much reduced space and                                                                
                                   obtainable at a much reduced capital cost.                                                                                          
                          P. Ex. 2002, col. 7,1. 66 - col. 8,1. 42.                                                                                                    
                F 35. Park 426 does not expressly describe intermittently applying vacuum or reduced pressure                                                          
                          during the exposure to microwaves.                                                                                                           
                F 36. Park 426 does not expressly describe hydrodistilling the natural product by conveying the                                                        
                          natural product and water as an azeotropic mixture and separating the natural product from                                                   
                          the azeotrope.                                                                                                                               
                                                      2) U.S. Patent 5,519,947 (Park 947)                                                                              
                F 3T Park 947 issued from an application said to be a continuation-in-part of the application that                                                     
                          issued as Park 426. P. Ex. 2001, col. 1, 11. 5-6..                                                                                           
                F 38. Park 947 relates to microwave assisted generation of volatile components from a variety of                                                       
                          materials. P. Ex. 2001, col. 1, 11. 10-12.                                                                                                   
                F 39. Par6 947 says that there is a need for a method of enhancing the volatility of the volatilizable                                                 
                          substances and for selectively separating the volatile component. P. Ex. 200 1, col. 2,11. 1-15.                                             
                F 40. Park 947 notes that using the microwave techniques of the invention, volatile components                                                         
                          for a variety of uses may be generated more easily with greater efficiency while allowing for                                                
                          less error and contamination. P. Ex. 200 1, col. 2, 11. 17-20.                                                                               
                F 41. Park 947 says the volatilization procedure is preferably performed in a sealed container. P.                                                     
                          Ex. 2001, col. 2,11. 25-29.                                                                                                                  
                                                                            -8-                                                                                        






Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007