Ex Parte PARE - Page 13




             F 84. Par6 947 refers to a "microwave oven" and "microwave applicator" as sources of microwave                      
                     energy. P. Ex. 200 1, Example 5, col. I Oý 11. 4-6 and the second Example 4; col. 12.11. 10-12.             
             F 85. Neither Par6 426 nor Par6 947 include the phrase "conventional microwave oven."                               
             F 86. Pard has not presented any evidence explaining how a person having ordinary skill in the                      
                     microwave extraction art would understand the disclosures of the Par6 patents.                              
             F 87. Pard has not presented any evidence explaining the meaning a person having ordinary skill                     
                     in the microwave extraction art would give to "microwave applicator" as that phrase is used                 
                     in Pard 426.                                                                                                
             F 88. Pard has not presented any evidence explaining the meaning a person having ordinary skill                     
                     in the microwave extraction art would give to "microwave applicator" and "microwave                         
                     oven" as those phrases are used in Par6 947.                                                                
             F 89. Par6 has not presented any evidence showing the meaning of a "conventional microwave                          
                     oven" to a person having ordinary skill in the microwave extraction art.                                    
             F 90. Neither Par6 426 nor Par6 947 have been shown to inherently disclose the use of a                             
                     conventional microwave oven.                                                                                
             F 91. Neither Par6 426 nor Pard 947 have been shown to inherently describe applying microwaves                      
                     in pulses.                                                                                                  
             F 92. Pard has not provide evidence showing that the ideal gas equation is applicable to predict the                
                     behavior of systems including non-gaseous phases.                                                           
             F 91. Par6 has not provided evidence showing the ideal gas equation is applicable to systems                        
                     including a change of state from solid or liquid to gas.                                                    
             F 94. Pard has not provided evidence that the ideal gas equation is applicable to predict the                       
                     behavior of the mixture of gases in the sealed-containers described by the Par6 patents.                    
             F 95. Neither Pard 426 nor Pard 947 has been shown to inherently describe the intermittent                          
                     application of reduced pressure during microwave treatment.                                                 
                                           2) The Ganzler Publication                                                            
             F 96. The Ganzler publication does not expressly describe "intermittently applying a vacuum to                      
                     the biological material" or "intermittently applying reduced pressure."                                     


                                                            13 -                                                                 






Page:  Previous  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007