Ex parte BOONE et al. - Page 14




          Appeal No. 95-1220                                                          
          Application 07/972,279                                                      



          that Appellants have not argued any specific limitation, but                
          only argue whether those skilled in the art would have reasons              
          to make the modification.                                                   
                    The Examiner argues on page 12 of the answer that                 
          Boone teaches all of the limitations recited in Appellants’                 
          claim 24 other than “a slit for passing the rotated sensor                  
          input image therethrough.”  The Examiner argues that Peppers                
          teaches a slit for passing replicated sensor input images in                
          column 11, lines 7-14 [sic, 7-15] and column 8, lines 10-20,                
          as well as a detector array in column 8, line 67, through                   
          column 9, line 6.  The Examiner also shows that Boone suggests              
          using a slit as a reference image for determining angular                   
          cross-correlation in column 10, lines 15-21.                                
                    At the outset, we note that Appellants have                       
          indicated on page 5 of the brief the groupings of the claims.               
          In par-ticular, Appellants state that claims 7 and 24 stand or              
          fall together.  In addition, on page 9 of the brief,                        
          Appellants    argue claims 7 and 24 as a group.  37 CFR §                   
          1.192(c)(5) amended October 22, 1993 states:                                
                    For each ground of rejection which                                
                    appellant contests and which applies to                           
                                          14                                          





Page:  Previous  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007