Ex parte BARTON et al. - Page 9




          Appeal No. 96-0899                                                          
          Application 07/863,216                                                      

          responsive to operation of a particular one of the keys to buffer           
          and store a key activation packet that is passed onto the central           
          controller in response to a polling request.  The claim also                
          requires the central controller to generate an indicator control            
          packet that is sent to a particular keyboard and visual indicator           
          cluster controller in response to receipt of the key activation             
          packet.                                                                     
                    While the examiner has cited various references for               
          teachings of polling, entering of physician instructions into a             
          computer system and electrical communication between rooms and a            
          central location, it is not at all clear how the examiner intends           
          to modify Auer with this combination of teachings in order to               
          arrive at the claimed subject matter.  We would agree with the              
          examiner that polling techniques and general communication by               
          physicians and between rooms and central locations are generally            
          known.  However, this does not explain how the artisan would have           
          been led to the very specific communication system set forth in             
          claim 8 wherein each of the claimed coded selectively operable              
          keys corresponds to a predetermined physician order, wherein a              
          key activation packet is buffered and stored in response to                 
          operation of one of the keys and wherein the central controller             
          is responsive to the receipt of the key activation packet to                


                                         -9-                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007