Appeal No. 96-1511 Application 08/063,919 Copell discloses a general purpose holder device for receiving and holding articles such as “pipes, tooth brushes, toilet appliances and similar elements” (page 1, column 2, lines 8 through 10). The device consists of a body 10 preferably made of rubber or a similar material. The body includes an opening 12 for receiving the article and carries a mounting strip 17 which may be embedded into the surface of an underlying support to affix the body thereto. The opening 12 may define recesses or grooves 13 to accommodate oval-shaped articles. As best shown in Figure 3, Copell’s body has a base portion, a pair of resilient wing portions joined to the base portion along a junction location, and a longitudinally extending channel having opposite open ends and a longitudinal mouth. Copell’s holder device meets all of the limitations in claims 1, 2 and 7 through 9 except for those requiring the base portion to have opposite lateral edges (claim 1) and an adhesive layer on its bottom surface (claim 2), and the grooves to be triangular in cross-section (claim 8). In this regard, the base portion of Copell’s device lacks any apparent opposite lateral edges and adhesive on its bottom surface, and Copell’s recesses or grooves 13 are semi-circular in cross-section. 7Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007