Ex parte SMITH et al. - Page 7




          Appeal No. 96-3758                                                          
          Application 08/252,832                                                      


          form on an LCD display (column 2, lines 32-41).  The device                 
          includes a temperature sensor, an infrared sensor, a barometric             
          sensor, and a flux gate magnetometer to provide signals in                  
          helping to provide the desired navigation data for display                  
          (column 5, lines 18-56).                                                    
               The claim feature at issue is the requirement that                     
          supplementary navigation data is received from a local vehicle              
          station.  Neither the examiner nor do we regard Pitchford’s                 
          keyboard as such a local station in the context of the claimed              
          invention.  As reasonably construed in light of the appellants              
          specification, the local station has to be some facility outside            
          and remote of the vehicle in which the navigation device is                 
          installed, or in the case of Pitchford, a facility outside and              
          remote of the handheld and portable navigation device.                      
               Pitchford does, however, disclose the presence on its                  
          handheld navigation device an optical input/output port for                 
          serially interfacing the CPU of the instrument with another                 
          electronic device, computer or the like (abstract; column 2, line           
          68 to column 3, line 6).  The only description of any specific              
          use of this I/O port appears in column 7, lines 16-24 of the                
          specification:                                                              



                                          7                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007