Ex parte CHARNITSKI et al. - Page 3




          Appeal No. 95-2333                                                          
          Application 07/981,919                                                      

          § 103 as unpatentable over admitted prior art in view of                    
          Dannatt, Harrigan, and Hegg.                                                
                    Appellants’ specification describes admitted prior                
          art shown in Figure 1.                                                      
                    The examiner finds the admitted prior art discloses               
          all of the claimed subject matter except the aspects involving              
          deforming the lens array.  The examiner further finds that                  
          Dannatt discloses those aspects.  Still further, the examiner               
          finds that Dannatt suggested deforming the linear gradient                  
          index lens array in the admitted prior art for the purpose                  
          disclosed by Dannatt of modifying the linearity of an emitted               
          swath of light without disturbing the focal adjustment.                     
          Examiner’s Answer at                                                        
          4-5.                                                                        
                    Appellants argue that Dannatt is non-analogous art.               
          Even if Dannatt were analogous art, appellants argue, Dannatt               
          seeks to improve focus and width characteristics of a scan                  
          line and does not suggest improving the write length on a                   
          photoreceptor surface by applying force to a linear lens                    
          array.  Appeal Brief at 11-13.                                              



                                         -3-                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007