Ex parte DUNN et al. - Page 5


          Appeal No. 95-2439                                                          
          Application No. 08/080,353                                                  

          references in a manner to overcome the individual deficiencies              
          and to arrive at the claimed subject matter.                                
               Appellants make several arguments against the examiner’s               
          position.                                                                   
               We agree with appellants, at page 6 of the brief, when                 
          they contend that Osafune teaches a conventional disk drive                 
          system which is preset to one of two power modes of operation               
          and that Osafune does not disclose monitoring the power supply              
          voltage to detect voltage drops nor does the reference                      
          disclose adapting the drive’s reset and seek parameters                     
          responsive to the changing voltage levels.                                  
               We also agree with appellants, at pages 6-7 of the brief,              
          that Morimoto relates to a voltage monitoring system which                  
          monitors the voltage of the power source at two levels and                  
          that the system stops the supply of current to the write and                
          erase circuits when the power supply drops below an upper                   
          level so that whenever the power supply drops below the upper               
          level but remains above a lower voltage level, the drive is                 
          used to perform read operations only.                                       
               However, appellants argue [brief, page 7] that the prior               
          art does not suggest “adjusting the reset and seek parameters               
          of the disk drive dynamically in accordance with variations in              
          power supply potential and a selected mode of operation” but                


                                          5                                           



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007