Ex parte SAWAGATA - Page 8




          Appeal No. 95-2855                                                          
          Application 08/075,338                                                      


          Once synchronization has been achieved, frames of data                      
          continue to be played as shown by the graph of time codes versus            
          time in Figure 2.  Because there is synchronization, and because            
          there is only one memory enabled by the comparator, the                     
          additional synchronized playback of frames of data indicated by             
          the graph of Figure 2 would have to come from the same memory               
          which has already been selected.  In other words, once the memory           
          holding the starting frame of data has been determined,                     
          synchronization thereafter is maintained by selecting the output            
          of that particular memory as shown in Figure 2.                             
          As we noted above, the question is whether the original                     
          specification conveys that appellant was in possession of the               
          invention now being claimed at the time the first application was           
          filed.  It is clear from the original specification, for reasons            
          discussed above, that the original specification expected that              
          playback of a videotape would continue after synchronization was            
          obtained.  It is clear from the original specification that the             
          invention picks one of the memories 14-1 to 14-i for playing back           
          frames of data which are synchronized to the desired playback of            
          the data recorded on the videotape.  Therefore, we agree with               
          appellant that the original specification does provide support              
          for the invention now being claimed.  Accordingly, we do not                

                                          8                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007