Ex parte KING et al. - Page 6




                Appeal No. 95-3292                                                                                                      
                Application 08/115,975                                                                                                  


                The display selection and combination circuit is connected to the first and second image memories                       
                and it is formed such that the display units display a combination of data from the image memories                      
                according to a display request.  Usually, one of the first and second image memories stores                             
                character information, such as letters and numerals, and the other stores graphic information, such                     
                as figures and curves.  The system is able to display graphic data and character data individually                      
                or in combination, so as to prevent inadvertent deletion of character data due to interference from                     
                graphic data or vice versa.  In achieving his improvement, Fujisaku resorts to two display units                        
                rather than the single display unit of the prior art.                                                                   
                        Ichikawa addresses the problem of displaying a sender’s message on a single display unit                        
                of a paging receiver, the display unit having a limited number of display segments available.                           
                Ichikawa lacks any suggestion of using a plurality of display units, one to display a short message                     
                and another to display a long message all at once, or of transmitting character and graphic data to                     
                a paging receiver.  Fujisaku teaches the use of plural display units in a display system designed to                    
                prevent the inadvertent deletion of character and graphic data experienced in prior art display                         
                systems.  Although Fujisaku concerns the display of character and graphic data on separate                              
                display units, it lacks any suggestion of transmitting character and graphic data in a paging system                    
                from a transmitter to a receiver.  Neither Ichikawa nor Fujisaku, alone or in combination, appears                      
                to provide any incentive to combine their teachings.  The inadvertent deletion of character and/or                      
                graphic data, the problem which Fujisaku seeks to overcome, is not a problem in Ichikawa.  Such                         
                being the case, there appears to be no teaching or motivation which would have suggested to one                         
                                                                   6                                                                    





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007