Ex parte WOODLE et al. - Page 3




          Appeal No. 95-4004                                                          
          Application 07/858,171                                                      
                    by said injecting, achieving at least about a ten-                
               fold increase in the concentration of liposomes in the                 
               infected tissue over that achievable by the [sic] such                 
               liposomes in the absence of the amphipathic vesicle-forming            
               lipid derivatized with said polyethylene glycol.                       
               Having meticulously reviewed the specification, the claims,            
          the prior art cited against the claimed invention, the Appeal               
          Brief, and the Examiner’s Answer, we find that the examiner has             
          not satisfied his burden to establish a prima facie case of                 
          unpatentability of the claimed subject matter under 35 U.S.C.               
          § 103 in view of the combined teachings of Popescu,                         
          Radhakrishnan, and McGregor.  We find that no single prior art              
          reference cited against the subject matter claimed describes the            
          “diacyl-chain amphipathic vesicle-forming lipid derivatized with            
          polyethylene glycol having a molecular weight between about 350             
          and 5,000 daltons” which is a required component of the vesicle             
          forming lipids which comprise the liposome composition                      
          administered by intravenous injection in accordance with the                
          method of Claim 1.  Moreover, the prior art considered as a whole           
          would not have reasonably led persons having ordinary skill in              
          the art to make and use the vesicle-forming lipids which comprise           
          that liposome composition to administer a therapeutic compound              
          effective against a source of infection by intravenous injection            
          as per the method of Claim 1.                                               



                                        - 3 -                                         





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007