Ex parte COOMBS et al. - Page 21




          Appeal No. 95-4152                                                          
          Application 08/042,044                                                      

          vision display which "contains adjustment mechanisms for tilt               
          adjustment, eye relief, and interpupillar adjustment" (col. 7,              
          lines 29-31).  The tilt adjustment (figure 2) is for movement               
          in the vertical direction and the eye relief (figure 8) and                 
          interpupillar adjustment are for movement in the horizontal                 
          direction.  In addition, the mounting assembly can be adjusted              
          in the vertical direction in the visor slot 14 (e.g., col. 6,               
          lines 59-68).  We agree with the examiner's conclusion that it              
          would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art to              
          provide adjustments of the sensor camera in Hanson in view of               
          the adjustments taught in Burbo.  Appellants argue that "Burbo              
          merely teaches horizontal and vertical adjustment mounting of               
          vision equipment but adds nothing to Hanson with regard to                  
          suggesting the mounting of an infrared sensor camera                        
          underneath the brim of a helmet" (Br25-26).  Thus, appellants               
          essentially argue that claim 8 is patentable because it                     
          depends on claim 1.  Since we conclude that claim 1 is                      
          unpatentable, we sustain the rejection of claim 8.                          
               Claims 13 and 14 recite that the centerline of the                     
          display is displaced downwardly at an angle between 0E to                   
          about 10E.  Hanson shows a pivotal connection 108 for a                     

                                       - 21 -                                         





Page:  Previous  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007