Ex parte HIRAYAMA - Page 5




          Appeal No. 95-4629                                                          
          Application 07/831,953                                                      



          display area it may not protrude from the visible area of the               
          display, thus causing the correction means clause to be                     
          inoperative or not needed in the context of the overall                     
          claimed invention.  Even still, the function of the correction              
          means is that it "corrects the position of the window image so              
          that the image area of the window image is displayed in the                 
          visible area."  This language of the correction means clause                
          of independent claim 1 on appeal is more explicitly recited in              
          both the correction means and detection means clauses of                    
          independent claim 5 on appeal, with the same end result when                
          the same claimed "conditions" are followed through, that is,                
          answered in the positive or the negative.                                   
               From our review of the disclosed invention, it appears                 
          that independent claim 1 is apparently directed to focus on                 
          the disclosed "first aspect" of the disclosed invention.                    
          However, the scope of claim 1, as noted by the examiner, is                 
          much broader than appellant's arguments appear to obtain.                   
          Initially, we observe that there is no automatic correction                 
          that occurs which is plainly an intent of the disclosed                     
          invention.  Secondly, the function of the correction means is               

                                          5                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007