Ex parte LOGAN - Page 7




          Appeal No. 95-5059                                                          
          Application 08/157,872                                                      


               Using the language of claim 1 as a guide, Daimler Benz                 
          discloses a vehicle body extension that is capable of being                 
          mounted on the exterior surface of a vehicle in the region                  
          surrounding a wheel opening.  While Daimler Benz does not show a            
          wheel opening per se in the drawings, the shape of the body                 
          extension (Figure 1) clearly indicates that it is complementary             
          to a wheel opening, and a wheel is shown in Figure 2.  The                  
          Daimler Benz unit is in the form of a contoured sheet-like body             
          having an inner edge (the lower right-hand edge of panel 11 in              
          Figure 2) which generally conforms to the shape of a wheel                  
          opening (see Figure 1), and an outer edge (generally at the upper           
          15 in Figure 2) which is nonconforming to the shape of the wheel            
          opening and which is capable of fitting generally conformingly to           
          a vehicle fender.  The contour of the body being exposed, when              
          mounted on a vehicle, reveals a protuberant region adjacent the             
          inner edge (the lowermost of the downwardly curved portion of               
          element 11 in Figure 2), a shoulder region extending from the               
          protuberant region toward the outer edge (the uppermost of the              
          downwardly curved portion of element 11), a reverse-turned region           
          between the shoulder and selected portions of the outer edge (the           
          upwardly curved corner portion immediately beneath the lead line            
          to the numeral 14 in Figure 2), and a nonprobuberant border                 

                                          7                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007