Ex parte SAADEH - Page 4




          Appeal No. 95-5064                                                          
          Application 08/049,463                                                      

          a long enough period of time (e.g., 13 ms), the voltage on the              
          capacitor reaches the threshold voltage (e.g., 20 volts) of a               
          voltage-sensitive switching device 42, which then quickly                   
          discharges the capacitor through LED 46 in a photo-optic coupler            
          44.  The light pulse emitted by the LED drives the phototransitor           
          48 in the photo-optic coupler into conduction for about 50 µs,              
          thereby generating a 5-volt pulse for application to the latch              
          circuit, which triggers the shut down circuit.                              
                    The examiner contends, and Appellant does not dispute,            
          that it would have been obvious to connect peripheral computer              
          equipment to the output terminals 18 ("LOW DC") of Konopka's                
          power supply 16, thereby satisfying the requirement of claim 1              
          for "an electrical load connected to the source for operation at            
          an operating voltage above a predetermined level."  As a result,            
          the sole question before us is whether Konopka thus modified                
          satisfies the remaining limitations of the claim.  For the                  
          following reasons, we agree with Appellant that the answer is no,           
          because Konopka thus modified does not include the claimed "power           
          storage means connected to the load for supply of said operating            
          voltage thereto" or the claimed "impedance means connected to the           
          power storage means for regulating . . . discharge thereof into             
          the load during said interruption in power of the source."                  


                                         -4-                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007