Ex parte HIKMET et al. - Page 5




               Appeal No. 96-1368                                                                                                  
               Application 08/080,891                                                                                              


               Instead, the birefringent polymer material in Figure 8 is                                                           
               layer 74, which is located between elements 72a and 72b,8                                                           
               which are formed of glass or other isotropic material (col.                                                         
               30, lines 18-25).  This is consistent with Rogers's statement                                                       
               that "[t]he polymeric materials utilized in the devices of the                                                      
               present invention can be variously formed or shaped into                                                            
               films, sheets, coatings, layers, fibrils, fibers or the like"                                                       
               (col. 21, lines 3-6).   As a result, Rogers's suggestion of9                                                                                   
               using polymeric birefringent material in a Wollaston prism                                                          
               (col. 30, lines 39-60) appears to be a suggestion to use a                                                          
               layer of such material between isotropic wedge-shaped                                                               
               elements.  Rogers also fails to disclose that the birefringent                                                      




                       Element 72b is incorrectly labeled 72 in the figure.8                                                                                                          
                       The birefringent polymer material used in the other9                                                                                                          
               disclosed embodiments is likewise in the form of a layer or                                                         
               film.  Specifically, in the light polarizing sheet shown in                                                         
               Figure 5, the birefringent material is in the form of a                                                             
               lenticular layer 16 between isotropic layers 14 and 18 (col.                                                        
               25, lines 7-11 and 38-44).  In the headlamp of Figure 6, a                                                          
               prismatic birefringent polymer layer 42 abuts a prismatic                                                           
               isotropic layer 44 (col. 28, lines 1-6).  Figure 7 shows a                                                          
               multilayer polarizing sheet 50 having alternating layers of                                                         
               birefringent polymer material 54 and isotropic material 56                                                          
               (col. 28, lines 35-38).                                                                                             
                                                             - 5 -                                                                 





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007