Ex parte SIMON et al. - Page 6




          Appeal No. 96-2191                                                          
          Application 08/395,512                                                      


               On the other hand, in the matter of a turntable intended               
          for rotating food being cooked in a microwave oven, the patent              
          to Pomeroy teaches those versed in the art to house the                     
          turntable drive means in a shielding enclosure.  As explained               
          by the patentee (column 5, lines 9 through 16), the outside of              
          a metallic enclosure 45 is covered with a layer of electrical               
          insulation to reduce arcing to the shield.  It is noted by                  
          Pomeroy (column 5, lines 27 through 29) that the amount of                  
          microwave energy which enters the motor housing or enclosure                
          is negligible.                                                              

               This panel of the board fully appreciates the examiner’s               
          understanding of the applied prior art and point of view as to              
          the obviousness of the claimed invention, as expressed in the               




          answer.  However, when we set aside what appellants’                        
          application teaches us regarding the present invention, and                 
          focus upon the evidence of obviousness as a whole, we do not                
          discern any sug-gestion that would have been fairly derived by              
          one of ordinary skill in the art for modifying the metal food               

                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007