Ex parte HILL et al. - Page 6




          Appeal No. 96-2712                                                          
          Application 08/313,548                                                      


               Notwithstanding appellants' above-noted arguments to the               
          contrary, we find nothing in Coit, Clark or Standal which would             
          preclude each of the clearly flexible card carrying mailing                 
          folders of these references from being considered to be an                  
          "automatic insertion adapted carrier form" (emphasis added), as             
          set forth in appellants' claims on appeal.  In this regard, we              
          note particularly that Coit (page 1, lines 86-90) indicates that            
          the sheet (1) of the mailer therein is formed of "suitable stock,           
          which is preferably somewhat heavier and somewhat stiffer than              
          the usual writing paper."  Thus, it is apparent to us that the              
          paper stock used in Coit would inherently possess a degree of               
          stiffness and flexibility so as to be capable of use in an                  
          appropriate automatic insertion apparatus and that the corner               
          pockets (defined by the slits 2 and tabs 3, or slits 7) would be            
          inherently capable of resiliently flexing from the planar body of           
          the mailer when the planar body is automatically bent to open the           
          pockets for receipt of one of the two pairs of opposed corners of           
          the card to be received therein.  As a further point regarding              
          appellants' argument that the carriers of Coit, Clark and Standal           
          are not "adapted for automatic insertion," we expressly note that           
          appellants have provided no explanation or evidence in support of           
          this bare assertion.                                                        

                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007