Ex parte OLSEN - Page 6




          Appeal No. 96-3225                                                          
          Application 08/229,322                                                      


          coating of reflective material, prior to the application of                 
          color.  Thereafter, an imagewise pattern of color is applied                
          over the reflective composition.  See pages 12 and 13.                      
               This gives rise to two differences from the method                     
          recited in claim 16.  First, the claim requires that the color              
          be applied first and the reflective material thereafter;                    
          however, in the Danish reference the opposite is the case.                  
          Second, the claim also requires that the reflective material                
          be applied in a “second graphic segment . . . in a second                   
          imagewise pattern,” whereas in the Danish method the                        
          reflective material is applied in a coating over the entire                 
          sheet.                                                                      
               Palmquist discloses a reflector for use as a road sign or              
          the like.  It comprises a base layer upon which have been                   
          deposited, seriatim, a reflective layer, a transparent color                
          layer, and a binder layer in which a plurality of spheres are               
          embedded.  There is no teaching of making either the                        
          reflective or the color layer in an “imagewise pattern.”                    
          However, as the examiner has pointed out, the Palmquist system              
          manifests itself in color being visible in the daylight and                 
          reflected color being visible under illumination by vehicle                 
                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007