Ex parte RICH - Page 9




          Appeal No. 96-4144                                         Page 9           
          Application No. 08/169,019                                                  


          circuit board in a position of engagement with the flange 25.               
          Rotation of the rod member 30 is accomplished by use of a tool              
          45, a slotted end 46 of which engages a drive pin 47 extending              
          transversely through the adjacent end of the rod member 30.  To             
          limit rotation of the rod member 30 to approximately the desired            
          ninety degrees, there is provided a stop pin 48 which also                  
          extends transversely through the rod member 30 at a location                
          spaced from the drive pin 47.  To accommodate the stop pin there            
          is a stop slot 49 in the block 24 at opposite ends of which are             
          stop shoulders 50 and 51.                                                   


               The examiner's statement of this rejection (answer, pp. 4-5)           
          is                                                                          
               Husted '601 discloses a hanging rack apparatus for holding a           
               printed circuit panels comprising in combination, a pair of            
               slot means (consider two end opening 29 of the rod 24, fig.            
               6) having a first vertical surface (27, fig. 3), a second              
               vertical surface (27, fig. 3), and sloped surface (29, fig.            
               3) extending upwardly from the second vertical surface (27),           
               a pair of roller means (consider the curved portions 33 and            
               34 at each end portion of 30 as in figure 3) movable on the            
               slope surface for holding the circuit panel (14), a block              
               (consider the portion of 30 between 33 and 34), a stem (47)            
               secured to the block for moving the roller means (33 and 34,           
               fig. 4) upwardly on the sloping surface for releasing the              
               panel.                                                                 

               For the reasons set forth by the appellant (brief, pp. 9-10            
          and 12), we conclude that claim 1 is not anticipated by Husted.             







Page:  Previous  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007