Ex parte MERMELL - Page 7




          Appeal No. 97-4205                                                          
          Application 08/562,853                                                      


          access panel not be visually distinct from the means for                    
          permanently securing the remaining panels.  Turning to the                  
          teachings of Luisada, the removable access panel or top 114 is              
          secured by three separate means, i.e., (1) the arrangement in               
          Fig. 12 wherein the securement of the removable access panel 114            
          to the back panel 28 is illustrated, (2) the arrangement in Fig.            
          10 wherein the securement of the removable access panel 114 to a            
          side panel 102 is illustrated and (3) the arrangement in Fig. 7             
          wherein the securement of the removable access panel 114 to the             
          front panel 64 is illustrated.  While the securing means                    
          illustrated in Fig. 12 is visually similar to the means for                 
          securing the back, side, front and bottom panels, the securing              
          means illustrated in Figs. 10 and 7 are not.  That is, as                   
          illustrated in Fig. 12 the securement means includes an angle               
          member 120, 122 which is spaced from the back panel by a visually           
          discernable gap or space.  The means for securing the back, side,           
          front and bottom panels together all similarly have a visually              
          discernable gap or space.  On the other hand, the securing means            
          illustrated in Figs. 10 and 7 have no such visually discernable             
          gap or space.  Furthermore, (1) the securing means illustrated in           
          Fig. 10 includes a downwardly extending plate 126 that extends a            
          significant distance downwardly at a location near the back 28,             

                                          7                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007