Ex parte TOHILL et al. - Page 4




          Appeal No. 98-0459                                                            
          Application 08/658,719                                                        


          addresses a contact lens storage compartment as a structural                  
          entity which comprises at least one additional storage                        
          compartment exterior or outside of its main storage body                      
          compartment, which main storage body compartment is coverable by              
          the hinged top cover.  This claimed contact lens storage                      
          compartment is, of course, clearly not simply two physically                  
          separate and distinct structural entities, one a storage body                 
          compartment and another a distinct additional storage                         
          compartment.3                                                                 

               We turn now to the teachings of Jessen, Cuppari, and Nathan,             
          applied to claim 1.                                                           

               Cuppari teaches two pairs of contact lens carriers or                    
          storage compartments 36, 38, 40, and 42, but these contact lens               
          storage compartments are all interior of the main storage body                
          compartment under the hinged and mirrored lid or cover 18.                    

               Jessen teaches a temporary storage contact lens cleaning kit             
          that includes one pair of contact lens storage cups 20 and caps               


               3As an example, Cuppari and Nathan respectively evidence two separate    
          and distinct storage compartment entities, not a contact lens storage         
          compartment comprising a main storage body compartment and at least one       
          additional lens storage compartment exterior to the main storage compartment, 
          as set forth in claim 1.                                                      
                                           4                                            





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007