WANG V. TUCHOLSKI - Page 135




          Interference No. 103,036                                                    


          32, 42, and 49.  The motion relies upon the testimony of                    
          Dr. Feder at CR 72 and 73, who testified that Burroughs et al.'s            
          specification, column 6, lines 48 to 52, only discloses that:               
                              The indicator material can be any                       
                    material that will undergo a visible change,                      
                    such as a color change, when the voltage                          
                    potential across the electrodes exceeds or                        
                    drops below a predetermined voltage.                              
          According to Dr. Feder, the foregoing recitation does not                   
          disclose colorless indicator materials or transitions from color            
          to colorless or colorless to color for indicator materials.                 
          Further, Dr. Feder testified that the foregoing recitation is               
          directed to those types of indicator materials which are voltage            
          sensitive color indicator materials, not to heat sensitive color            
          indicator materials.  The motion is denied as to this item.                 
                    We agree with the party Burroughs et al.'s opposition             
          brief, pages 146 and 147 that the Burroughs et al. specification            
          has sufficient written description for the foregoing limitations.           
          As noted by the party Cataldi et al., Burroughs et al., column 6,           
          lines 48 to 52, disclose that the indicator material can be any             
          material that will undergo a visible change, such as a color                
          change.  Burroughs et al., column 8, lines 59 to 62, teaches that           
          one of the strips is made of a material that is sensitive to                
          temperature and will undergo a visible change when the                      
          temperature exceeds a predetermined value.  The term, "color                



                                        -58-                                          



Page:  Previous  128  129  130  131  132  133  134  135  136  137  138  139  140  141  142  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007