WANG V. TUCHOLSKI - Page 133




          Interference No. 103,036                                                    


          "label" and the "label with an integral voltmeter."  For this               
          reason, we find the testimony of Dr. Powers to be credible where            
          he urges that the battery indicator device which is carried on              
          strip 12 constitutes a label.  Accordingly, the motion is denied            
          with respect to this limitation.                                            
                    In item 10, the motion urges that the Burroughs et al.            
          specification does not contain a written description for the                
          "thermochromic inks," "thermochromic tapes," and "crystalline               
          materials" limitations of reissue claims 41 and 48.  The motion             
          relies upon the testimony of Dr. Feder at CR 70 to 72, who                  
          testified that Burroughs et al.'s specification does not disclose           
          or suggest thermochromic inks or thermochromic tapes and using              
          thermochromic ink in a voltage indicator device.  Dr. Feder                 
          testified that the specification discloses using liquid                     
          crystalline materials not in an indicator device 10D but in                 
          embodiments that use voltage sensitive liquid indicator material            
          and that have the indicator chamber, cell, or bubble that is used           
          to hold the voltage sensitive liquid indicator material.  The               
          motion is denied.                                                           
                    We agree with the party Burroughs et al.'s opposition             
          brief, pages 144 and 145, that the Burroughs et al. specification           
          has sufficient written description for the foregoing limitations.           
          Burroughs et al., column 6, lines 56 and 57, broadly disclose               



                                        -56-                                          



Page:  Previous  126  127  128  129  130  131  132  133  134  135  136  137  138  139  140  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007