BARKER V. ELSON et al. - Page 9




          Interference No. 103,146                                                    



          date.  In summary, the cover sheet prepared and signed by                   
          Edgell is suppressed on authentication and hearsay grounds.                 
          The balance of the document is not suppressed on                            
          authentication or hearsay grounds to the extent that it                     
          provides evidence of what was conceived as per Barker’s                     
          testimony at least as to the date the sketch, page 000068, was              
          prepared, i.e., December 8, 1981, but is suppressed on hearsay              
          grounds to the extent that it is said to offer evidence of                  
          conception as of October 1981.  The same result obtains with                
          respect to the suppression of BX-122.                                       
                    With respect to BX-119, this is a series of progress              
          reports which Barker testified that he authored.  Since these               
          reports were authored by Barker, his testimony can                          
          authenticate them.  These reports will not be suppressed for                
          lack of authentication.                                                     
                    With respect to the BX-120, Barker provides                       
          authentication.  With respect to the date of the document,                  
          this uncertainty goes to the weight to be accorded the                      
          document not whether it can be admitted at all.                             
                    With respect to BX-121, this document is suppressed               
          for the reasons given by the senior party.  Barker is unable                
                                          9                                           





Page:  Previous  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007