Appeal No. 95-4209 Application No. 07/862,486 disclosure regarding the employment of cobalt in an amount of 9% or below, molybdenum in an amount of 12% or below, tungsten in an amount of 6% or below and boron in an amount of 0.05% or less in an alloy can be interpreted as not requiring the presence of all of the above-mentioned components. Specifically, Tsuji states (page 3) that: Particularly, among the precipitation-hardening Ni- based heat-resistant alloys for forging (which are currently put to practical use), those which have the 10 h creep rupture strength of 80MPa or higher at3 871EC contain 10% or more of Co without exception (as shown in Figure 1). Unfortunately, Co is an expensive element. If a precipitation-hardening Ni-based heat-resistant alloy for forging is developed with a low Co content, it will be cost- efficient. Cobalt is effective in raising the Young’s modulus of the alloy at a high temperature and in decreasing the mean thermal expansion coefficient at a high temperature. See page 10. Molybdenum and tungsten, on the other hand, are necessary for effectively reinforcing the base material of the alloy by solid dissolution. See pages 10 and 11. Also, molybdenum, like cobalt, is effective in lowering the mean thermal expansion coefficient. See page 10. According to Tsuji, 4Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007