Ex parte LEVINE et al. - Page 9




          Appeal No. 1995-4366                                       Page 9           
          Application No. 08/150,744                                                  


               Regarding claims 169-175, 184, and 185, the appellants                 
          argue, “Lin does not teach a data processor which recognizes                
          commands contained in an image and executes the recognized                  
          command.  Adachi fails to cure this deficiency.”  (Appeal Br.               
          at 7.)  They add, “Lesnick, for different reasons, also fails               
          to cure the deficiency of Lin.”  (Id. at 8.)  The examiner                  
          replies, “Adachi disclosed ... the part of the facsimile                    
          transmission used for cyclic redundancy check ....”                         
          (Examiner’s Answer at 4.)  She adds, “Lesnick et al. also                   
          disclosed ... the header page which specifies which operations              
          are to be performed ....”  (Id.)  We agree with the                         
          appellants.                                                                 


               Independent claim 169 specifies in pertinent part “said                
          local data processor receiving said facsimile image and ...                 
          recognizing specified data processor commands contained within              
          the received image, and executing the recognized specified                  
          data processor commands.”  Similarly, independent claim 184                 
          specifies in pertinent part “the data processor recognizing                 
          information contained within the received image data as                     
          commands and ... retrieving stored information specified by                 







Page:  Previous  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007