Ex parte FISH - Page 4




          Appeal No. 95-4615                                                          
          Application No. 08/158,853                                                  


               With respect to claim 1 through 19, the examiner states                
          that the Hawke reference discloses "all aspect of the [claimed              
          features] except [sic, for] the instantly recited... keyways                
          [and keys]..."  According to page 7 of the specification, the               
          terms "keyways" and "keys" recited in claims 1 and 7 are                    
          defined as follows:                                                         
                         As Figure 4 shows, the lower edges of the                    
                    panels are formed with beveled surfaces 50 to                     
                    facilitate installation.  When adjacent side                      
                    panels are placed in position, the complementary                  
                    channels 46 and passages 48 become aligned and                    
                    form a keyway 44 accessible from the upper                        
                    surface of the panels.  Castable refractory,                      
                    preferably KRICON 30 XR or KRIFORM 30 XR low                      
                    water vibrating castable, is placed into the                      
                    passages, flows into the channels, fills the                      
                    channels and passages, dries, cures and hardens,                  
                    thereby providing a structural connection among                   
                    the side panels, referred to hereafter as keys                    
                    45.                                                               
          To remedy the deficiencies of the Hawke reference, the                      
          examiner relies on the Beckman reference.  Beckman discloses                
          using a shear link (keyways and keys) between "concrete units,              
          such as slabs, panels, etc...," to "add additional shear                    
          strength and reduce the shear stress supported by the cement                
          grout in the joint" between adjacent concrete units.  See                   
          column 1, lines 40-50 together with columns 3 and 4.  The                   

                                          4                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007