Ex parte CHANG et al. - Page 7




          Appeal 96-0460                                                               
          Application 08/150,303                                                       

               We will also note that the applicants have caused                       
          considerable confusion on the record and therefore have not                  
          been of much assistance in certain respects.                                 
               Applicants rely on two declarations in an effort to                     
          overcome the examiner's rejections.  Both declarations make                  
          reference to Example 1 of the specification.  There is no                    
          Example 1 in the specification.  Furthermore, there is a                     
          reference on page 7, lines 11-12 of the specification to                     
          "Examples recited hereinafter, especially in Examples 16-25                  
          ***."  We have not been able to find Examples 16-25 in the                   
          specification.  We are concerned that neither the examiner nor               
          applicants carefully read the specification.  We also are                    
          concerned as to whether the declarants or the examiner                       
          carefully read the two declarations.                                         
               Since the declarations mention Example 1 of the                         
          specification and there is no Example 1 in the specification,                
          in reaching our decision, we decline to give any weight to the               
          declarations.  We leave it to applicants and the examiner to                 






                                        - 7 -                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007