Ex parte CROWELL et al. - Page 5




          Appeal No. 1996-0721                                                          
          Application No. 08/036,640                                                    


                                   R-SO -NH-CO-NH-R                                     
                                       2           1                                    
          in which” R is, inter alia, a substituted or unsubstituted                    
          phenyl, aliphatic or cycloaliphatic hydrocarbon radical and R1                
          is                                                                            
          -(CH) C H .  See column 1, lines 19-51.  According to the                     
               n 65                                                                     
          examiner (Answer, page 3):                                                    
                    The sole difference between [sic, the] herein                       
               recited claims and the [Korger] reference appears to                     
               be in the definition of R  in the reference.                             
                                         1                                              
          To remedy this deficiency of the Korger reference, the                        
          examiner relies on the disclosures of McLamore and Lucius.                    
          McLamore describes medicinal agents for reducing blood sugar                  
          levels having a formula                                                       
                                    RSO NHCONHR’,                                       
                                       2                                                
          wherein R’ is “a lower alkyl, lower alkenyl or cycloalkyl                     
          group or it is an aryl group.”  See pages 1 and 2.  Similarly,                
          Lucius describes compounds for lowering blood sugar having a                  
          formula                        RSO NHCONHR ,2       1                                   
          wherein R  is “saturated or unsaturated alkyl, cycloalkyl,1                                                                    
          cycloalkylalkyl, phenylalkyl or phenyl group...”  See page 2.                 
          Nowhere do these references teach, or would have suggested,                   
          employing the claimed halophenyl radical as R  of the general                 
                                                        1                               
                                           5                                            





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007