Appeal No. 1996-1291
Application No. 08/182,409
columns 2 through 4, with Takiyama, columns 2 through 4.
Nowhere does either Kitabatake and/or Takiyama indicate that
the chemicals of the type described in Takiyama are useful for
the transfer method described in Kitabatake. See Takiyama and
Kitabatake in their entirety. Nor does Golchert remedy this
deficiency. See Golchert in its entirety. To employ the
chemicals described in Takiyama in the transfer method of
Kitabatake is to destroy the invention on which Kitabatake is
based, for the use of such chemicals materially compromises
the objectives of Kitabatake. See Ex parte Hartmann, 186 USPQ
366, 367 (Bd. App. 1974). Accordingly, we cannot sustain any
of the examiner’s § 103 rejections.
7
Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Next
Last modified: November 3, 2007