Ex parte ASKMAN et al. - Page 4




          Appeal No. 96-1548                                                          
          Application 08/288,127                                                      


          contacts the strands and draws and continuously conveys the                 
          strands through the length of the pipe”.                                    
               Oki discloses a cooking process for pasta (noodles) where              
          the raw materials along with warm water are poured into the                 
          inflow tank and heated while passing through the water conduit              
          pipe by hot water around the pipes (Oki, page 6, “(Effect)”;                
          page 8, last paragraph).  Oki teaches that there is no direct               
          heating of the warm water surrounding the noodles but the                   
          noodles are boiled and cooked in the boiling water conduit by               
          the hot water in the water conduit tank (page 10).  Oki does                
          teach vertical flow (i.e., gravitational flow) from the inlet               
          to the outlet end of the pipes (page 8, last paragraph, and                 
          Figure 1).                                                                  
               The examiner applies Ohki (cited by Oki as “Prior Art” at              
          page 3) to show the cooking of pasta or noodles by conveying                
          the hot water and noodles in cooking tubes (see the Final                   
          Rejection, page 2).  However, Ohki does not disclose a                      
          vertical or gravitational flow of noodles and water but uses a              
          vacuum pump to produce a partial vacuum to convey the noodles               
          through the pipe structure (see Ohki, pages 2, 6 and 7).  In                
          fact, Ohki teaches away from the use of gravitational flow                  

                                          4                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007