Ex parte BARSHAD et al. - Page 6




          Appeal No. 96-1625                                                          
          Application No. 08/096,106                                                  


          sample, or both is then collected and analyzed” (column 1,                  
          lines 17 through 19).                                                       
               The Abstract of Birang discloses the following:                        
               A photometer [14] having a plurality of input fibers                   
               to its optical entrance [16], at least one [78] of                     
               which is for transmission of calibration light and                     
               at least one [77] of which is for transmission of                      
               sample light.  The exit ends of these fibers are                       
               aligned into a linear array [Figures 7B, 7E and 8A],                   
               thereby producing an effective entrance slit for the                   
               optical entrance of the photometer.  The fiber(s)                      
               for calibration light are positioned at the center                     
               of the linear array to avoid miscalibration due to                     
               photometer astigmatism.                                                
               Smith discloses a chopperless spectroanalytical system                 
          (Figure 1) that teaches simultaneous detection of a sample                  
          beam 14 and a reference beam 34.  The two beams are                         
          “concurrently monitored and compared to compensate for errors               
          due to source fluctuations and the like” (column 1, lines 49                
          through 51).                                                                
               The examiner is of the opinion that the fiber 38 and the               
          Y-coupler 40 of Lequime are a fiber optic bundle that is                    
          split into a first leg and into a second leg (Answer, pages 3               
          and 11).  The examiner is also of the opinion that it would                 
          have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art to use                
          the fiber optic bundle teachings of Birang in Lequime to                    
                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007