Appeal No. 96-1895 Application 08/011,682 track following (position control) operations in Kanda correspond to the claimed "settling operation." Kanda has a phase compensation circuit (PCC) 31, the purpose of which is described as follows (col. 2, lines 25-30): "The phase compensation circuit is composed of a filter, such as a notch filter and lead lag filter, and adapted to suppress a resonance point in a mechanical system, such as a carriage and to prevent an oscillation phenomenon resulting from a phase delay." Thus, PCC 31 serves the same purpose as appellant's low pass filter. The question is whether the PCC 31 in Kanda is turned OFF and ON as recited in the claims. Kanda discloses (col. 4, lines 54-66): A fifth switching circuit 36 is turned ON at a time of track following operation and delivers the position signal PS from the position signal generator 20 to the integrating circuit 30. An integrating circuit 30 integrates the position signal PS from the position signal generator 20 to deliver a result of integration to a PCC (phase compensation circuit) 31. PCC31 [sic] is composed of a filter, such as a notch filter and a lead lag filter. A third switching circuit 32 is turned ON at a time of track following operation to supply a compensated replica of the position signal coming from PCC31 [sic] to the motor driving circuit 27. - 12 -Page: Previous 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007