Appeal No. 96-1895 Application 08/011,682 Appellant argues that Abed and Kanda do not disclose the following features of the independent claims: (1) "a configuration of a positioning control system, in which a low pass filter is constituted by an adequate combination of a notch filter and an elliptical function filter (Br12); and (2) "turning ON the low pass filter by a switching operation when a seek operation proceeds to a track following operation" (Br12). (1) Low pass filter comprising notch filter and elliptical function filter Claim 1 recites a positioning control system having a "low pass filter which has an abrupt slope and a discontinuous pole in the gain-frequency characteristics thereof . . . wherein said lowpass [sic] filter comprises a notch filter having said abrupt slope for suppressing a lowest resonance frequency and an elliptical function filter having said pole for suppressing a second lowest, or higher, resonance frequency." Claim 9 recites a positioning control system having a "low pass filter which has an abrupt slope and a discontinuous pole in the gain-frequency characteristics thereof . . . wherein said low pass filter - 6 -Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007