Appeal No. 1996-3162 Application 08/227,897 The air which is added to the primary oxidation chamber 400 through the annular air distributor 409 appears to repeatedly flow up and down through the mass of feed material M in the primary oxidation chamber 400, as is illustrated by the arrows A and B in Figure 5, this continuous recirculation of air, which progressively changes in composition to the gaseous oxidized feed material, being facilitated by the hemispherical shape of the dome 404 of the primary oxidation chamber 400. They further disclose that the recirculating effect may be enhanced by the use of vertical flutes 413 in the chamber wall (page 10, lines 16 to 20). At the same time, the incompletely oxidized gaseous effluent passes from chamber 400 through duct 412 to secondary oxidation chamber 600 (page 9, lines 15 to 22; page 11, lines 1 to 3). The examiner interprets the claim 1 language in question as calling for the establishment of "a split flow of gaseous effluent with one portion repeatedly recirculating and another further portion directed in an outward direction" (answer, page 7). Thus, as claimed, according to the examiner, one portion of the effluent recirculates, apparently 6Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007