Appeal No. 96-3486 Application No. 08/291,565 catalyst, while enhancing their beneficial effects on activity” (page 2, lines 26-29). It goes on to say that “[t]he invention more particularly defined is directed to step (a) [see claim 1]: atomizing an aqueous suspension containing at least one mixture of a powder of a refractory inorganic oxide with a solution of at least one cerium oxide precursor salt and at least one iron oxide precursor salt and, optionally, other compounds, soluble or insoluble, that are part of a composition suitable to form a porous layer . . . to be deposited on the substrate. . .” (page 4, lines 16-25). Atomization, though a conventional3 method for making powder, contrasts with the prior art techniques for achieving an incorporation of the refractory inorganic oxide, and cerium and iron salts. According to appellants (specification, page 2, lines 20-24), the prior art techniques include impregnating the refractory inorganic oxide. This difference in technique has an implication on the performance of the catalyst. Tests (specification, 3 Specification, page 8, lines 31-33: “In order to achieve the atomization step (a) of the process according to the invention, every conventional apparatus can be used.” 6Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007