Ex parte NILSSEN - Page 27




          Appeal No. 96-3618                                                          
          Application 08/004,598                                                      

          discloses a wireless telephone unit attached to a conventional              
          mobile telephone unit.  The mobile telephone unit may be of                 
          the cellular type (col. 3, lines 61-66) and is connected to a               
          battery power supply 156, as shown in figure 2; the mobile                  
          telephone unit comprises a "cordless base station."  Since the              
          mobile telephone unit is cellular, it has a transceiver to                  
          communicate with a cellular telephone system, as recited in                 
          claim 28; in this respect we disagree with the Examiner's                   
          reference to element 210 in Gillig (2dSEA53), because element               
          210 is part of the cellular cordless telephone, not part of                 
          the first receiver as claimed.  The wireless telephone unit                 
          "may comprise any of the well-known commercially available                  
          units which are intended for wireless operation" (col. 3,                   
          line 66, to col. 4, line 1).  It would have been obvious to                 
          combine the cellular cordless telephone of Gillig with a                    
          mobile telephone unit as taught in Duffy to obtain the                      
          wireless advantages of Duffy (e.g., col. 1, lines 6-21), and                
          because Duffy states that any commercially available telephone              
          unit can be used (col. 3, line 66, to col. 4, line 1) (which                
          would include a cellular cordless set as taught by Gillig),                 
          and because Gillig teaches that the cellular cordless                       

                                       - 27 -                                         





Page:  Previous  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007